The death spiral we had to have
I wrote my first story about Bitcoin in 2011. In the 11 years since, I’ve spent a lot of time reading, writing and thinking about cryptocurrency.
So, trust me when I say that the rapid-fire implosion of the LUNA-UST ecosystem is one of the top five most consequential events I’ve ever witnessed in crypto. In the space of 48 hours, roughly US$45 billion of notional value simply disappeared. The Luna Foundation Guard, proud buyers of US$3 billion of Bitcoin last month as “insurance”, were forced to basically sell it all in a failed effort to save the chain.
Who could have seen this coming? Well, lots of people. Hell, the exact mechanism that took LUNA down was publicly mooted by a CFA last November, at which point Do Kwon, LUNA’s founder, publicly ridiculed him.
In effect it wasn’t entirely dissimilar to George Soros’ infamous attack on the British pound in 1992. However, the British pound is backed by, well, Britain, whereas LUNA was backed by an algorithm that responded to negative pressure with a burst of hyper-hyperinflation to put Zimbabwe to shame.
And now you have a worthless stablecoin backed by a worthless blockchain and a convenient narrative for every regulator and crypto skeptic to confirm their long-simmering suspicions about the space. Thanks Do Kwon!
Vote for us
Wemoney Crypto Awards
We’re finalists in the Wemoney Crypto Awards! We’d love it if you could take a few seconds to vote for us in the People’s Choice poll. I’m not saying this is a bigger deal than the election, but…
Cleaning out the stables
The UST fiasco has shone the spotlight squarely on the stablecoins that fuel the crypto market. With numerous UST clones out there – Near, Fantom and Tron all recently got in on the action – enterprising whales began wondering if they too could destroy a blockchain.
While there haven’t been any casualties so far, many stables have temporarily lost their pegs, either in the face of concerted attack, or simply from investors getting the hell out of Dodge.
Tether, the largest stablecoin, was not immune, despite being a fully collateralized (as opposed to algorithmic) stablecoin. Long the subject of rumours and accusation as to the accuracy of their accounts, the price of one USDT dropped to 95 US cents as skittish holders sought safer refuge.
While that depegging was largely a market effect, there has been real world follow through. Over the last week Tether has redeemed US$9 billion in USDT tokens for USD, the first significant redemption since late 2018, when USDT shed about 30% of its market cap.
As a general rule, stablecoin issuance functions as a proxy for market enthusiasm. Over the last two years, Tether’s market cap has gone 20x. With the markets shaky and the mood dismal, it’s unsurprising to see some of that money flowing elsewhere.
Overheard on Twitter
I’m unironically more bullish now that the foundational cracks of our industry have exposed themselves.
I think there’s a lot more pain to come unfortunately, but on a bigger picture scale, this was a necessary evil for the space to mature and continue on.
Hello darkness, my old friend
The Fear & Greed index has, unsurprisingly, been hitting some historic lows. We are terrified – and not without cause. The macroeconomic picture is grim. Hacks and collapses have become endemic. Bitcoin just printed its 7th straight negative week, something that has never happened before. Like in 2018, the question is being asked: has crypto’s value overshot its usefulness?
If this is a new crypto winter, here are three things we know:
- It will be hard: many coins will die, others will lose 98% of their value. And before you think “I’m already 90% down, the end is in sight!”, that would involve the price dropping another 80%. Endless failed breakouts will sap your hope reserves, the news will be remorselessly negative and the crowing from the anti-crypto folks will be deafening.
- It will end: eventually, one of those breakouts will stick. A new narrative will emerge. Long dead crypto Twitter accounts will come back to life. New user counts will tick upwards and you’ll start reading about 10x coins once more. Before you know it, another halving will be on the horizon and – fingers crossed – the good times will kick off once more.
- It takes work: The choices you make during the downturn are the ones that could pay you back (literally) a hundred fold down the track. Filter out the hype, trade cautiously and find interesting projects with strong use cases backed by respected teams. Bear markets are where people build the things that will fuel the next bull run. Recognising that is the hard part.
Good luck, stay safe and happy trading.
Luke from CoinJar
CoinJar UK Limited is registered by the Financial Conduct Authority as a Cryptoasset Exchange Provider and Custodian Wallet Provider in the United Kingdom under the Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017, as amended (Firm Reference No. 928767). Like all investments, cryptoassets carry risk. Due to the potential volatility of the cryptoasset markets, the value of your investments may fall significantly and lead to total loss. Cryptoassets are complex and are currently not financial products regulated by ASIC or the FCA, and you are not able to access the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) or the UK Financial Service Compensation Scheme or the UK Financial Ombudsman Service in relation to any dispute with CoinJar relating to trading in cryptoassets. We use third party banking, safekeeping and payment providers, and the failure of any of these providers could also lead to a loss of your assets. We recommend you obtain financial advice before making a decision to use your credit card to purchase cryptoassets or to invest in cryptoassets. Profits may be subject to Capital Gains Tax.